Det som forbauser meg litt, er at ingen har grepet fatt i det faktum at 
leverandører som NGT tar betalt for IP-adresser. Det er direkte i strid 
med reglene fra RIPE; der står det helt tydelig at man kan ta et 
administrativt engangsgebyr for å tildele adressene, men ikke en fast 
leie. Prisen kan heller ikke variere med antallet adresser.



RIPE sine retningslinjer er ikke så klare som du gir uttrykk for. Det
aktuelle dokumentet (RIPE-152) sier:

  Two of the above services involve the assignment of finite resources
  to customers: these are domain name space and IPv4 address space.
  They are managed and assigned by registration agencies, respectively
  domain name registries and IP registries. By themselves, these
  resources have no intrinsic value; their worth is only realised in
  conjunction with the provision of Internet access. Thus, while
  registries may charge for their administrative and technical
  services, they may not charge for name space or address space as
  such; no unit cost or price tag can be attached to a domain name or
  to an IP address, public or private.

Dette bør nok tolkes dithen at man ikke kan selge IP-adresser, men at
man fritt kan ta seg betalt for administrasjon av dem, ruting av dem
osv. At NextGenTel har valgt å legge en større del av kostnadene ved
fast-IP-løsningen sin på de som trenger flere adresser bør ihvertfall
være greit.





Og et utklipp fra deres "ISP customer FAQ" som linker til RIPE-152
http://www.ripe.net/ripencc/faq/isp-customers.html#14

How much should an LIR be charging for requesting IP space on my behalf?
IP addresses are a public resource and should not be bought or sold. It is
reasonable, however, for an LIR to charge a fee for administering the
address space that they assign to you. The RIPE NCC has not stipulated a
charging schedule. This is left to the discretion of the membership.

Further information on the RIPE community's policy on charging by LIRs can
be found in the RIPE document "Charging by Local Internet Registries" found
at:

http://www.ripe.net/ripe/docs/chargingbylirs.html

Men det jeg finne prinsipielt feil er at ISP'n leverer en RFC-1918 adr. på
sin terminerings punkt til kunden.



Les denne tråden: 
http://groups.google.com/groups?hl=no&lr=&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8&threadm=EK9f9.3533%24TK2.344234%40juliett.dax.net&rnum=1&prev=/groups%3Fq%3Dsamuel%2Bgunnestad%2Bngt%26hl%3Dno%26lr%3D%26ie%3DUTF-8%26oe%3DUTF-8%26selm%3DEK9f9.3533%2524TK2.344234%2540juliett.dax.net%26rnum%3D1